ANTI HADEETH DILEMMA WITH THE QURAN PT 1

Below is an article that I had previously forwarded to
ROPE. The article explains to us CLEARLY why the Anti
Hadeeth THEORISTS like Ali Mohammed, Sulaiman Yahya,
KASSIM AHMAD etc EMBRACED THE ISA WITH OPEN ARMS.

It is becuase the ENGLISH QURAN that they believed in
DOES NOT show them examples or even mention about the
concept of DUE PROCESS. By their standard,DUE PROCESS
is UNQURANIC.

Since the Quran has specified to us a NUMBER of
punishment for a number of offences such as SARIQ(
Stealing), Zani (Fornication) and many more, we are
REQUIRED to carry put such punishment for such
offences stated in the Quran.

The Anti Hadeeth (GAH) theorist have always
accused the AHLUL HADEETH(AS) as introducing
BACKWARDNESS

and UNPROGRESSIVE ideas in the Muslims mind thus being
the reason for the Muslim ummah backwardness (despite
the fact that 1400 years of history proves them
otherwise).

Here I shall expose to you WHO's idea would actually
STOP the Muslims from progressing and who will not

DUE PROCESS
GAH: There is NO VERSES in the Quran that specifies

DUE PROCESS for the OFFENCES and PUNISHMENT stipulated
in the Quran or otherwise. No orders for Due process
to be given to those SUSPECTED of STEALING,
FORNICATING etc or any offence for that matter.

Therefore, there is no such thing as DUE PROCESS in
the GAH understanding of ISLAMIC JURISPRUDENCE

Surah 17:73 - And their purpose was to tempt thee
away from that which We had revealed unto thee, to
substitude in Our name something quite different:
(in that case), behold! They would certainly have made
thee (their) friend!

AS: Due Process is DEMONSTRATED clearly by the
PROPHET SAW for ALL offences and their respective
punishment.

The manner of due process by the Prophet SAW is being
practiced even until today in countries which
practices Roman Law.

Conclusion: If we go by the GAH way of ISLAMIC
JURISPRUDENCE then we shall only see
MASSIVE injustice and cruelty being comitted as there
is no such thing as DUE PROCESS being practiced by
the GAH.

AND, for 1400 years the MUSLIMS have enjoyed RULE OF
LAW by following the SUNNAH of the PROPHET derived
from his Sunnah.

AUTHORITY IN CARRYING OUT PUNISHMENT
GAH: No requirement for AN AUTHORITY to carry out
punishment as stipulated in the Quran. Meaning ANYONE
can carry out the punishment regardless of who.

AS: Only a RECOGNISED AUTHORITY has the right to TRIAL
and PUNISH an offender for the offences stated in the Quran.

Conclusion: The GAH way of JURISPRUDENCE will only
introduce ANARCHY and PUBLIC DISORDER not to mention
LAWLESNESS in a country as NO MENTION
of the need for an authority is mentioned in the Quran.

On the other hand, for AS it has been SHOWN by the
PROPHET via his SUNNAH that only a RECOGNISED
AUTHORITY is ALLOWED to conduct trial and execution of
punishment for the offences stipulated in the Quran

In addition, the SUNNAH of the PROPHET SAW taught of
us including the WEST of concepts such as DOCTIRNE OF
SEPERATION OF POWERS, RULE OF LAW, DUE PROCESS
and many more concept which lead the Westeners out of
their BARBARIC PERIOD into their RENNAISSANCE era.
Please refrain from interpreting the QUran with WHIMS
and FANCIES.


REFER SURAH 2:78&79
REFER SURAH 2:59
REFER SURAH3:78
REFER SURAH 39:32

May Allah SWT protect us from the DEVIATIONS being
promoted by the GAH.